Showing posts with label AC 4. Show all posts
Showing posts with label AC 4. Show all posts

Sunday, October 27, 2024

The Commemoration of the Reformation

The Commemoration of the Reformation (observed) – October 27, 2024
Psalm 34; Revelation 14:6-7; Romans 3:19-28
St. John 8:31-36

In the Name of the Father, and of the + Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen.

“[Our churches] teach that men cannot be justified before God by their own strength, merits, or works, but are freely justified for Christ’s sake, through faith, when they believe that they are received into favor, and that their sins are forgiven for Christ’s sake, who, by His death, has made satisfaction for our sins. This faith God imputes for righteousness in His sight.”[1]

The Commemoration of the Reformation is primarily an occasion of giving thanks to God for working through an insignificant Augustinian friar to return the Church to her first love – Christ and His pure Word.[2] It is meet, right, and salutary to learn about the history of our faith. The Reformation was the most significant event in the western church since the Second Council of Nicaea, and Martin Luther was the instrument, chosen by God, to spark that Reformation. Luther was a theological genius. He was a prolific writer. He knew how to strike out against the proud sinner and console the suffering conscience.

But if we allow our minds to focus the history of the Reformation on the person of Martin Luther, we are no better than the Medieval Roman Catholic Church who worshiped the saints. If today we sing the praises of Martin Luther as having worked to reform the Church by his own means, then we may as well pray to St. Jude that all children who have renounced the faith return home.

“If you abide in My word, you are My disciples indeed. And you shall know the truth, and the truth shall make you free.”[3] Our Lord is speaking these words to the Jews who had believed in Him. These are the ones who heard the Word of God and were amazed. Their intellects were intrigued by the teaching of this One who taught not as the Pharisees but with authority. They are standing in the place of the Medieval Church and Christians of all time who hear preaching that pricks their consciences but do not yet understand. 

And yet these Jews could not help themselves but lie. “We have never been in bondage to anyone.”[4] They make this statement during the Festival of Booths, that occasion where the people of God recalled the deliverance from slavery in Egypt by the hand of God. They have not forgotten their own history. Rather, Christ’s admonition to abide in His word has pricked their consciences. The Law of God has struck their hearts. They have not abided in God’s Word. They have not familiarized themselves with the basic teachings of the Scriptures. They have not treated the Word of God as being spoken to them by the lips of their heavenly Father.

The immediate reaction of these Jews to such an accusation of the Law is to lie. “We’ve never been enslaved – not in our lifetime, nor our father’s, nor ever since the time of Abraham. We’ve never been enslaved physically, nor spiritually enslaved to the worship of a false God. Why would we need to be set free?” What’s more is that these Jews have placed their salvation in being descended from Abraham. They have the right blood in their veins and so they will be loved by God.

There is a temptation for Christians that whatever occurred in the life of the church during the time most significant to me is the purest form of the Church. For many of us, it might look like our childhood. The way our childhood church was conducted is the height of Lutheranism. Perhaps it was during our middle age, when we had a close group of friends in the church – that was the height of Lutheranism. Perhaps we are tempted by descriptions of history. The way Luther conducted the service, THAT was the height of Lutheranism.

All are error and all are sin. They are sinful because they rely on the actions of humans to determine the height of the Truth of the Word of God. Christ is calling us to abide in His Word, and this Word is Truth, and this Truth shall make you free. There is nothing new under the sun. There were just as many erring pastors in the age of Martin Luther as there are today. There were just as many sinners in the Church of the fourth century as there are in the twenty-first. The ideal Church is not found on earth, it is found in the worship of heaven. It is found in the Word of God.

It is easy on a day celebrating the Reformation to claim, “We are Lutherans, sons and daughters of Pure Doctrine. We’ve never been enslaved to anyone!” especially for those of us raised in the church. Perhaps a slightly different claim is harbored in your heart: “I belong to the right church, therefore I am saved! I have the Lutheran blood in my veins therefore I am loved by God!” You probably can’t remember a time before your Baptism. You can’t remember a time when you were a slave to sin who did not know “Jesus Loves Me.” The memory of man is short and just as likely to lie as remember anything at all. All men are conceived in iniquity and born in sin. You were born as a child of wrath.

Jesus gently rebukes these Jews and tells them, “Most assuredly, I say to you, whoever commits sin is a slave of sin. And a slave does not abide in the house forever.”[5] To sin against the Word of God by ignoring it or preferring the desires of your own flesh, wraps a chain of bondage around you. The more you struggle against the Word of God, the more you give in to your flesh – be it neglecting the Word of God, hating your neighbor, or lying against your conscience – the tighter the chains become and the easier it is to sin. Sin becomes your habitus, your way of life.

No matter the “purity” of your church, no matter the warm feelings your church family may give you, no matter how Christian you feel, no matter the claim of membership in the right Church or the claim of your family in the right church – sin makes you a slave. The slave of sin may dwell in the House of the Lord for a time. He may dwell in the House of the Lord his entire life on earth. But the slave of sin will not dwell in the House of the Lord for eternity. The slave of sin will be cast out into hell.

There is, however, an important distinction to be made. Our Lord says, “whoever commits sin is a slave of sin.” We are born slaves to sin, and all unbelievers are slaves still. They are slaves by nature. “But a son abides forever.”[6] The Christian is a son by nature. In Holy Baptism, you were adopted as a child of the Heavenly Father, an heir of the Kingdom of God. You are a child of heaven. Children of the Father remain in the House of the Lord forever!

The Christian is not a slave to sin by nature but to continue in sin, to commit sin returns you to a life of slavery. The chains of your bondage have been removed by the cleansing flood of Baptism and yet to return to sin, as a dog returns to vomit, is to once again pick up your chains and wrap them around your wrists. It is for this reason we, whose conscience has been made clean, must flee from sin. We must abhor sin. We must be disgusted by sin; by our own sin and by the sins of those around us. And when you find the steel links tightening their grip upon you, hardening your conscience and weighing down your soul, seek relief. Seek relief in repentance. Seek relief in the Word of God. Seek relief in confessing your sins. Seek relief in the Words of the Holy Absolution, proclaimed by the Pastor with his hands upon your head. Then, the chains will release their grip, climb the arms of your Pastor, sail past his shoulders and onto the shoulders of Christ.

“If the Son makes you free, you shall be free indeed.”[7] Jesus Christ, True God and True Man has set you free by his Blood. He who knew no sin, humbled himself to be bound with the chains you deserve. He wrapped himself in the chains of your sin and bore them to the cross. Those chains, your chains, weighed him down such that the torture of crucifixion, usually lasting hours, if not days, took only three hours to kill him. The weight of the sin of the world is great and it was born by Christ.

This same Christ rose from the dead to make you free. He bore the chains of your sin into the grave so that in his Resurrection, he could break the chains of your bondage. The Son has made you free in his death and Resurrection. This freedom was then delivered to you in your Holy Baptism. You have been made free indeed.

This freedom is not the freedom of this world. Especially as Americans and descendants of the Enlightenment, we think of freedom as freedom of opportunity, if not freedom of outcome. We think of freedom to act as we please and then the freedom to endure the consequences, be they positive or negative. This is not the freedom of God. American freedom is freedom of the flesh and the flesh profits nothing.

The freedom won for you by Christ is the freedom from sin such that you are free to serve God and neighbor. The freedom won for you by Christ is the freedom to live as a child of God. You do not need to obey the Law of God under the threat of losing your salvation. As a child of God, you have the Law of God to teach you how to live in your freedom. When you abuse that freedom, when you return to your flesh, then the Law once again pierces your heart and accuses you of sin. On this side of glory, such will always be the case.

Yet the New Man wrought within us by the death of Christ longs to obey the Law, not out of threats, but out of love. The New Man desires to be the ideal child of God. This is the man who has been set free by the Son and is free indeed. He is free to submit himself to God, to His Law, and to His Love.

This freedom of Christ is also a freedom to recognize the work of the Holy Ghost within his saints. It is by this freedom that we recognize what a miracle was wrought in Martin Luther. Only by the working of God and the incredible, heroic faith bestowed upon that lowly friar, was Luther able to accomplish any of what he did. Today, we reap the benefits of what God did through Martin Luther and we give thanks that the Lord saw fit to bless us in this way.

In + Jesus’ name. Amen.



[1] AC IV. Romans 3-4.

[2] This is an edited and updated version of the sermon preached in 2021.

[3] St. John 8:31-32.

[4] St. John 8:33.

[5] St. John 8:34-35.

[6] St. John 8:35.

[7] St. John 8:36.

Sunday, October 30, 2022

The Commemoration of the Reformation

The Commemoration of the Reformation – October 30, 2022
Psalm 34; Revelation 14:6-7; Romans 3:19-28
St. Matthew 11:12-19

In the Name of the Father, and of the + Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen.

The term “antichrist” is used in the Scriptures in both a broad and narrow sense. The broad sense can be found in 1 John 2, in which all false teachers are called “antichrists.”[1] This broad sense is the plain understanding of the word. False teachers stand opposed to Christ, making them “anti-Christ,” “against the Christ.”

The narrow sense of the term “antichrist” is most clearly described in St. Paul’s second letter to the Church in Thessalonica, where he writes as follows:

Now, brethren, concerning the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ and our gathering together to Him, we ask you, not to be soon shaken in mind or troubled, either by spirit or by word or by letter, as if from us, as though the day of Christ had come. Let no one deceive you by any means; for that Day will not come unless the falling away comes first, and the man of sin is revealed, the son of perdition, who opposes and exalts himself above all that is called God or that is worshiped, so that he sits as God in the temple of God, showing himself that he is God.

Do you not remember that when I was still with you I told you these things? And now you know what is restraining, that he may be revealed in his own time. For the mystery of lawlessness is already at work; only He who now restrains will do so until He is taken out of the way. And then the lawless one will be revealed, whom the Lord will consume with the breath of His mouth and destroy with the brightness of His coming. The coming of the lawless one is according to the working of Satan, with all power, signs, and lying wonders, 10 and with all unrighteous deception among those who perish, because they did not receive the love of the truth, that they might be saved. 11 And for this reason God will send them strong delusion, that they should believe the lie, 12 that they all may be condemned who did not believe the truth but had pleasure in unrighteousness.[2]

With St. Paul, we can identify 5 marks of this narrow use of the term “Antichrist.”[3] First, the position taken by the Antichrist is called the “falling away,” or apostacy. This means that the Antichrist will lead Christians away from the true doctrine of the Christ, especially the central doctrine of the Scriptures—that “man cannot be justified before God by his own strength, merits, or works, but is freely justified for Christ’s sake, through faith, when he believes that he is received into favor, and that his sins are forgiven for Christ’s sake, who, by His death, has made satisfaction for your sins.”[4]

The second mark of the Antichrist is that he will sit in the temple of God, that is, he will arise from within the Church itself. While it is tempting to claim any number of evil political leaders as “the Antichrist,” this would be contrary to Scripture. The Antichrist shall sit himself within the Church of God and attempt to deceive God’s children from such a position within the Church.

Third, the Antichrist will conduct himself in accord with this seat within the church, namely, he will act as if he was God, Himself. The Antichrist will claim supreme authority over man, refusing to submit to any other authority. He will claim to be above the authority of all creation and to be the soul source of God’s interaction with man.

The fourth mark of the Antichrist is that although he is not Satan himself, his coming and his reign will be built and backed by all manner of lying powers, signs, and wonders. Christ warns us that many will come in His name and even perform miracles, claiming to be from God.[5] All those claiming to be from God must be judged by their doctrine, and that according to the Word of God.

The final mark of the Antichrist is that he will remain until the return of Christ. The Lord will destroy the Antichrist at His visible return and yet, as St. John writes, “As we have heard that Antichrist shall come, even now are there many antichrists.”[6] It is this final mark that tells us the term “Antichrist,” when used in this narrow sense, refers not to an individual person, but to an office. An office endures longer than the lifetime of one man and yet remains unchanged until God destroys it.

These five marks are all fulfilled in the office of the Papacy, or the Roman Pope. At the Council of Trent, the Papacy officially declared the biblical doctrine of justification to be accursed, saying that anyone who teaches that man is declared righteous freely through the merits of Christ and cannot add to his own salvation according to his own works is anathema, that is, condemned to hell. Thus, in the Papacy, we can see the greatest and most pronounced “falling away” from the most fundamental article of faith by which man is saved.

Certainly, there are many others in the world who deny the doctrine of Justification, but the Papacy promotes such false doctrine from within the Christian Church. What I mean is that there are Christians in the Roman Catholic Church. There are Christians because they still receive Holy Baptism in the Name of the Triune God. The Holy Scriptures are still read and proclaimed. It is through these means that the Holy Spirit works faith in the hearts of man. It is a miracle of God that there are Christians who, despite the false teachings of the Pope and the seductive nature of the Church body to which they belong, still cling to faith in Christ, trusting in the death and resurrection of Jesus alone for their salvation.

In 1302, Pope Boniface VIII issued Unam Sanctum, declaring that it is necessary for salvation that man be subject to the Roman Pope above all others. This is a matter of official doctrine in the Roman Catholic Church. It is necessary for salvation that man be subject to the Pope above all other authorities on earth. This means that the Pope is above any criticism. It means the Pope alone is supreme in the Church and the world. He submits to no one.

Perhaps the most seductive to the eyes of man are the numerous reports of miracles, visions, and wonders related to the Roman Pontiff. Marian apparitions, miracles of healing, and statues that weep, bleed, or heal are all said to point to the validity of the papacy. In fact, these signs point to the contrary. Since they do not point to Christ, but instead to a man who claims greater authority than the Word of God, they are demonic in origin. I do not deny that some of these signs and wonders have occurred. In fact, I’m certain they have. However, they are signs fulfilling precisely the words of our Lord: “We played the flute for you and you did not dance; we mourned to you, and you did not lament.”[7]

Finally, in the papacy, we see an office that for a time after the apostles, remained beneath a veil. The early bishops of Rome were pious Christians who sought to lead the flocks God placed under their authority according to the Word of God. But after a time, and certainly by the 14th century, the nature of the Papacy was revealed to be the very seat of the Antichrist. It is an office which will endure until the return of Christ, when He will destroy the Papacy, along with all who fight against Christ and His reign in the Church.

Why is it worth studying the office of the Antichrist? St. Paul told us that he wrote concerning the man of lawlessness that you would not be “soon shaken in mind or troubled, either by spirit or by word or by letter.”[8] A proper understanding of the Antichrist is not necessary for salvation. Salvation is only gained by faith in Christ, a true understanding of the Son of God who took on human flesh to die on behalf of the sin of man, making atonement to the Father and sending His Holy Spirit to bestow such faith on man.

An understanding of the Antichrist serves as both a warning and a comfort. It is a warning in that it draws your attention to the one thing most needful—faith in Jesus Christ. It is a warning against fascination with the mysteries of God which He has chosen not to reveal to man. It is a warning against the seductive signs, wonders, and claims to history of the Roman Catholic Church.

It is a warning against seeing different churches as simply different social clubs. There are doctrinal differences between church bodies and doctrine is important. It is important whether you confess the biblical teaching that the Body and Blood of Jesus is truly present in the Holy Communion. It is important if you confess against the clear teaching of Scripture that one man is given all authority in heaven and earth to bestow salvation on whomever he chooses. These differences matter because given time, false doctrine will destroy faith. Even though there are Christians within the Roman Catholic Church, these Christians are in danger. They are in danger of falling into the trap of the Papacy and placing their faith in the salvation of the Pope, rather than the salvation of Jesus Christ.

The doctrine of the Antichrist is also a comfort, a consolation for your conscience because it forces you to examine the true doctrine of the Scriptures. Here you will find that it is not by your works that you are saved. You will find that there is nothing you can do to save yourself. There is no work you can perform, no amount you can pay, no decision you can make to escape the punishment of hell.

Only the perfect life of Jesus, who willingly kept the Law of God perfect from the moment of His conception to His death on the cross, merits salvation. Only the sacrifice of Jesus on Mount Calvary, willingly offered to the Father on your behalf, can atone for you sin. Only the work of the Holy Spirit, who has called you by the Word of God, the Holy Gospel, can draw you to salvation.

This is a comfort because it does not rely on you. It does not rely on how you feel or how much you understand. Your salvation relies on the Blood of Jesus, shed for you, and the faith bestowed upon you by God to cling to this Word of promise. The Pope in Rome would have you kneel before him in submission to his claim to authority. Jesus Christ submitted to death, even death on a cross for you. We now kneel before Jesus Christ alone, as He alone has called you by the Holy Gospel to join Him in eternity.

In + Jesus’ name. Amen.


[1] 1 John 2:18.

[2] 2 Thessalonians 2:1-12, quoted from the New King James Version (Thomas Nelson, Inc., 1982).

[3] Francis Pieper, Christian Dogmatics, Volume 3 (St. Louis, MO: Concordia Publishing House, 1953), 462-469.

[4] AC IV.

[5] St. Matthew 24:24.

[6] 1 John 2:18.

[7] St. Matthew 11:17.

[8] 2 Thessalonians 2:2.

Gaudete (Advent 3)

Gaudete – December 14, 2025 Psalm 85; Isaiah 40:1-11; 1 Corinthians 4:1-5 St. Matthew 11:2-11 In the Name of the Father, and of the + ...